Muggah Creek Watershed

Click here to sign petition to government
for cleanup to begin January 1, 2000


PUBLICATIONThe Standard (St. Catharines - Niagara)
DATE Tue 20 Jul 1999
EDITION FINAL
SECTION/CATEGORY Local News
PAGE NUMBERA5
STORY LENGTH 145
HEADLINE:

Firms will pay $7.1 million for Love Canal cleanup

BUFFALO, N.Y. - Two chemical companies agreed Monday to pay $7.1 million (U.S.) in cleanup costs for Love Canal, closing the book on the last of four Superfund sites that became a symbol of environmental peril in the late 1970s.

Occidental Chemical Corp., formerly Hooker Chemical, and Olin Corp. will reimburse the U.S. government $6 million and New York state $610,000 for the cleanup.

The companies also agreed to pay $500,000 for natural resource damages and undertake two wetlands restoration projects, EPA officials and a lawyer for Occidental said.

Some 900 families were uprooted from the neighbourhood because thousands of tonnes of dioxin, PCBs and other chemicals were buried at the site bordering the Niagara River.

The dumping ground was one of areas that led to the creation of the Superfund Program, which provides federal funding for the cleanup of the worst environmental sites nationwide.
PUBLICATIONThe Ottawa Citizen
DATE Tue 20 Jul 1999
EDITION FINAL
SECTION/CATEGORY News
PAGE NUMBERA1 / Front
BYLINETom Spears
STORY LENGTH 669
HEADLINE:

First proof: Pesticides, PCBs cause breast cancer:

Canadian researchers also find DDT speeds spread of disease

Canadian cancer researchers have found the first firm evidence that chemical PCBs and a banned pesticide called mirex cause breast cancer, in a three-year study that's the largest of its kind ever done.

And a parallel study, also Canadian, shows that exposure to DDT appears to make breast cancer spread faster when it does occur.

The World Conference on Breast Cancer, held every two years, will bring 1,000 delegates from 55 countries to Ottawa next week. The two new papers are to be presented during the conference.

They confirm what many women have feared -- that trace amounts of pollution can lie in the fatty tissue of the breast for a person's lifetime, and cause cancer there.

``These two studies are beginning to say to us: maybe there are things out there in the environment that are causing cancer,'' said Dr. Kristan Aronson of Queen's University, who led one of the studies.

``That's what the women are dying to hear about,'' she said. ``In one sense they're not wanting to hear it. (But) they want to know.''

Previous studies of chemicals in the bodies of women with breast cancer had failed to show a link between PCBs, an industrial oil banned in Canada in 1977, and the cancer.

But Dr. Aronson, an epidemiologist, says most past studies have looked at pollutants carried in the bloodstream.

And PCBs, being an oil, lodge for many years in the body fat of humans and wildlife alike.

Her study analysed tissue samples taken from more than 400 women during breast biopsies. Some were from women who had breast cancer while the others had non-cancerous lumps and cysts.

Dr. Aronson's teams looked at 14 different kinds of PCBs and 10 other pollutants. All 24 are called organochlorines, because they mix chlorine with organic chemicals, often petroleum-based.

Many organochlorines can last for decades in the environment without breaking down.

The 24 in her study include several banned pesticides -- mirex, hexachlorobenzene, DDT and the chemical that DDT forms when it breaks down, DDE. Of those, only mirex was linked to higher breast cancer rates -- and then only in women who have had babies but not breast-fed them.

We all have PCBs in our bodies, she said, but people who eat sport fish generally have higher levels of them.

(PCBs tend to wash into lakes and build up in the bodies of top predators such as bass, salmon and lake trout.)

Still, because PCBs have spread so widely through spills and dumping since their invention in the 1930s, ``it's difficult to say how to avoid them.''

The subject ``needs to be looked at a lot more,'' Dr. Aronson said.

``We're looking at 24 organochlorines and there are 15,000 of them out there'' in the environment.

PCBs -- polychlorinated biphenyls -- are actually a family of many similar oils once used in the electrical industry to keep water out of transformers and other equipment. While only some of the PCBs are associated with higher cancer risk, the whole range of different PCBs tends to be mixed in the food chain, especially in fish from contaminated areas.

Dr. Aronson's study used fatty breast tissue samples from 663 women in Toronto and Kingston hospitals between 1995 and 1997. Her full results are waiting to be published in a U.S. medical journal, Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers and Prevention.

She will discuss them at the conference next Wednesday. The conference is also going to hear from Dr. Alain Demers of Quebec City, whose study found that women with high DDT exposure have breast cancer that is ``more aggressive'' -- i.e., faster-spreading.

Paradoxically, these pollutants aren't dangerous in the way many women had feared.

Some chemicals, nicknamed ``gender-benders,'' mimic the action of the hormone estrogen and trick the body's hormone system. It has been suggested that this is the way pollution causes breast cancer.

But Dr. Aronson says there's nothing so devious about these chemicals because they don't act like estrogen on women's hormone systems.

They just cause cancer, and that's that.
GLOBE AND MAIL
TUE JUL.20,1999
PAGE: A14
BYLINE:
CLASS: International News
SOURCE: REUTERS
DATELINE: Washington DC
WORDS: 124
HEAD:

WORLD REPORT

HEAD:

UNITED STATES: Love Canal firms to pay $7.1-million

WASHINGTON Occidental Chemical Corp. and Olin Corp. have reached a $7.1-million settlement in the last of four cases in the Love Canal area of Niagara Falls, N.Y., the site of one of the most famous U.S. toxic-waste disasters. The companies will reimburse the federal government $6-million in cleanup costs, repay $610,000 in cleanup costs to the state of New York and pay $500,000 for damaging natural resources, federal and state agencies said yesterday.

Occidental's corporate predecessor, the Hooker Chemical Corp., began dumping toxic chemicals into the abandoned Love Canal in 1952. Residents began complaining in 1977 that toxic chemicals were seeping into their basements. More than 1,000 homes and an elementary school were evacuated.
Reuters

Read about the new
Community Alliance

Next article


Click here to see the similarities between Sydney and Love Canal
See Canada's Love Canal

Back to [In the News]



Nightmare on Frederick Street

Return to Main Page






1